Evaluating an AI automation vendor is usually treated as free. Demos cost nothing, proposals are free, and the internal meetings are absorbed into everyone's week. The cost appears later, when a weak choice produces a stalled pilot, a rebuild or a contract that cannot be exited without losing the data.
This guide breaks the evaluation into the work it requires, gives an effort formula for sizing it, and shows how to build a budget you can defend. It quotes no prices: the right figure depends on the use cases, the state of your data and how much risk the board wants to retire before signing.
What the evaluation is buying
A proper evaluation answers five questions: is the use case worth automating, can the vendor deliver it, is the data ready, are the risks acceptable, and do the commercial terms leave you in control. That is more than a demonstration.
The work includes a use-case shortlist, requirements and success measures, a vendor longlist, scripted demos, reference calls, security and data-protection review, a data-readiness assessment, a paid pilot, contract negotiation and a decision paper. Every step has a cost, even without an invoice.
Seven cost drivers
- Number of use cases. One bounded workflow is cheap to evaluate. Five candidates multiply workshops, demos and scoring.
- Number of vendors shortlisted. Every extra vendor adds a demo, a security questionnaire, a reference call and a scoring session.
- Integration complexity. Systems with documented APIs are easier to test than custom databases or desktop accounting tools.
- Data readiness. Messy records, scanned documents, mixed Bangla and English text, and unclear ownership add preparation time.
- Risk review depth. Customer data, payment information or regulated decisions require legal, security and privacy input.
- Pilot scope. A sandbox demo is not a pilot with real users, data and a success measure.
- Internal decision time. Stakeholders, finance, IT and the owner need to be in the same room at key points.
An effort formula for scoping
Use a points model to compare evaluations and forecast internal effort. It is not a price; it makes scope visible.
evaluation points = (use cases x 2) + (shortlisted vendors x 3) + (systems to integrate x 2) + (data sources needing cleanup x 3) + (regulated data x 4) + (pilot departments x 3)
Four use cases, three vendors, two integrations, two messy data sources, regulated data and one pilot department score 34 points. Record the person-days spent on your first evaluation, divide by its points and use that rate next time. Recalibrate after each round: a payment-data review is not an internal-notes review.
The formula also exposes scope creep. Two more vendors add demos, questionnaires and scoring. A second pilot department doubles the change and support load.
The budget lines
- Internal time: product owner, operations leads, IT, finance, legal and the people who will use the tool. Estimate hours, not "involvement".
- External adviser: optional, but useful when the team lacks AI procurement experience or needs an independent score.
- Security and privacy review: architecture review, data-flow mapping, contract clauses and any testing required by your policies.
- Data preparation: cleaning, labelling, access permissions and a representative test set. This is often the largest hidden line.
- Pilot licences and compute: vendor fees, model usage, storage and any integration environment.
- Test environment and integration: sandbox accounts, sample data, connectors and engineering time for a realistic pilot.
- Legal and contracting: review of data processing, liability, service levels, IP and exit terms.
- Contingency: hold a reserve for a second pilot round or a vendor that fails the security review.
A percentage guardrail
Finance teams want a single number. Set the evaluation reserve as a percentage of the first-year programme budget, then test it against the effort formula. A moderate, single-use-case programme may need only a low single-digit share; a multi-department programme with regulated data justifies more.
Treat the percentage as a guardrail, not a benchmark. If the formula exceeds the reserve, cut vendors or use cases rather than pretending the work is free. If it comes in under, spend the difference on a better pilot, not more demos.
Free pilots and paid pilots
A free demonstration is a sales event. It shows the vendor's best data, not yours. A paid pilot with defined scope should include a success measure, a data-handling agreement, a named team, a timeline and a decision gate.
Ask what happens to pilot data, whether prompts or outputs are retained, whether the vendor trains on your content, and how the pilot environment is separated from production. A pilot that cannot be audited is a preview.
Bangladesh-specific scope items
- Language quality: test Bangla, English and mixed-script messages. A demo in English may hide weak Bangla intent detection.
- Payment data: if the workflow touches bKash, Nagad, cards or cash-on-delivery records, test reconciliation and error handling, not just extraction.
- Connectivity: confirm how the tool behaves on a slow or intermittent connection, especially for field staff.
- Data labelling: budget time for your team to define correct answers and review samples. Vendors cannot label your business rules for you.
- Support hours: check whether the vendor's team works in your time zone and who responds during a month-end or festival peak.
- Documentation: confirm that invoices, contracts and data-processing terms meet your finance and audit requirements.
Red flags that raise the real cost
- A fixed "AI readiness" package with no defined outputs or acceptance criteria.
- Pricing only per seat, with no clarity on usage, model calls or data storage.
- No exit plan for models, prompts, embeddings or fine-tuned artefacts.
- A pilot that requires production data before a data-processing agreement is signed.
- Claims that the tool needs no human review for decisions affecting customers or money.
- No named team, no reference customer and no explanation of what happens when the model is wrong.
A 90-day evaluation plan
- Days 1-15: shortlist two or three use cases, define success measures and estimate data readiness.
- Days 16-30: issue a structured request to four or five vendors, with the same questions and a demo script.
- Days 31-45: run scripted demos, check references and complete security questionnaires.
- Days 46-65: run a paid pilot with real users and a defined test set. Measure accuracy, handling time and failure modes.
- Days 66-80: negotiate the contract, service levels, data terms and exit assistance.
- Days 81-90: write the decision paper with costs, risks and a go/no-go recommendation.
Score vendors on the same weighted criteria: use-case fit, evidence, data handling, integration effort, support, total cost and exit. Keep the scores and reasons; they protect the decision later.
AI automation evaluation is part of Business Automation. The pricing page explains how a pilot is separated from a production engagement. For the vendor comparison itself, read the year-by-year guide to AI automation vendor evaluation.
Sources
- NIST, AI Risk Management Framework, accessed 17 November 2026.
- ISO/IEC 42001, Artificial intelligence management system, accessed 17 November 2026.
- Gartner, governance across AI agents, accessed 17 November 2026.
- EU Artificial Intelligence Act, implementation timeline, accessed 17 November 2026.
Responses (0)
No comments yet. Add the first one below.
Leave a response
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.